| Selection | Team | Player | Position |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Castle Rock Fjords | Mark Prior | sp |
| 2 | Charleston Chiefs | Austin Kearns | rf |
| 3 | New York Jaywalkers | Damian Moss | sp |
| 4 | Mentone Beach Maulers | Rodrigo Lopez | sp |
| 5 | Starved Rock Magi | Eric Hinske | 1b |
| 6 | Miami Mercenaries | Josh Phelps | 1b |
| 7 | Arrowhead Griffins | Nick Johnson | dh |
| 8 | Rock Creek Disco Dancers | Carlos Pena | 1b |
| 9 | Braidwood Blast | Josh Beckett | sp |
| 10 | Harrisburg Senators | Hank Blalock | 1b |
| 11 | Castle Rock Fjords | Josh Fogg | mr |
| 12 | Braidwood Blast | Joe Crede | 3b |
| 13 | Bourbonnais Blackbirds | Sean Burroughs | 3b |
| 14 | Castle Rock Fjords | Jason Simontacchi | sp |
| 15 | Starved Rock Magi | Mark Ellis | 2b |
| 16 | Sioux City Soos | Ramon Vazquez | ss |
| 17 | Miami Mercenaries | Oliver Perez | mr |
| 18 | Atlanta Arrogants | Jake Peavy | sp |
| 19 | Scottsdale Cactus Riders | Carlos Zambrano | sp |
| 20 | Olympia Muscle | Bobby Hill | 3b |
| 21 | Olympia Muscle | Kazuhisa Ishii | sp |
| 22 | Miami Mercenaries | Mike Maroth | sp |
| 23 | Rapid City Mudhens | John Lackey | sp |
| 24 | Scottsdale Cactus Riders | Kevin Mench | lf |
| Selection | Team | Player | Position |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Atlanta Arrogants | Michael Cuddyer | rf |
| 2 | Charleston Chiefs | Kurt Ainsworth | sp |
| 3 | New York Jaywalkers | Alex Sanchez | cf |
| 4 | Braidwood Blast | Brett Myers | sp |
| 5 | Las Vegas DiamondBucks | Carl Crawford | lf |
| 6 | Los Angeles Hogheads | Ty Wigginton | 1b |
| 7 | Arrowhead Griffins | Rafael Soriano | cl |
| 8 | Rock Creek Disco Dancers | Jon Rauch | mr |
| 9 | Castle Rock Fjords | Kirk Saarloos | mr |
| 10 | Toronto Storm | Orlando Hudson | 2b |
| 11 | Bourbonnais Blackbirds | Tim Spooneybarger | mr |
| 12 | Las Vegas DiamondBucks | Reggie Taylor | cf |
| 13 | Olympia Muscle | Carlos Hernandez | sp |
| 14 | Braidwood Blast | John Patterson | sp |
| 15 | Syracuse Comets | Dustan Mohr | rf |
| 16 | Las Vegas DiamondBucks | Colby Lewis | sp |
| 17 | Sioux City Soos | George Lombard | cf |
| 18 | Toronto Storm | John Stephens | sp |
| 19 | Olympia Muscle | Denny Stark | sp |
| 20 | Scottsdale Cactus Riders | Josh Bard | c |
| 21 | Bourbonnais Blackbirds | Endy Chavez | rf |
| 22 | Braidwood Blast | Joaquin Benoit | cl |
| 23 | Toronto Storm | Jeremy Affeldt | mr |
| 24 | Rock Creek Disco Dancers | Runelvys Hernandez | sp |
| Selection | Team | Player | Position |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Bourbonnais Blackbirds | Aaron Cook | sp |
| 2 | Braidwood Blast | Ricardo Rodriguez | sp |
| 3 | New York Jaywalkers | Juan Rivera | 1b |
| 4 | Braidwood Blast | Mark Hendrickson | mr |
| 5 | Mentone Beach Maulers | Scot Shields | mr |
| 6 | Mentone Beach Maulers | Mike Koplove | mr |
| 7 | Arrowhead Griffins | Tony Fiore | mr |
| 8 | Rock Creek Disco Dancers | Jason Lane | cf |
| 9 | Castle Rock Fjords | Carlos Silva | sp |
| 10 | Kansas City Revenants | Mike Crudale | mr |
| 11 | Mentone Beach Maulers | Jack Cust | dh |
| 12 | Harrisburg Senators | Brendan Donnelly | mr |
| 13 | Baldwin Bombers | Morgan Ensberg | 3b |
| 14 | Miami Mercenaries | Michael Tejera | mr |
| 15 | Syracuse Comets | Pete Walker | mr |
| 16 | Sioux City Soos | Omar Infante | 2b |
| 17 | Baldwin Bombers | Tom Wilson | c |
| 18 | Charleston Chiefs | Nick Neugebauer | sp |
| 19 | Castle Rock Fjords | Ramon Santiago | 2b |
| 20 | Bourbonnais Blackbirds | Zach Day | mr |
| 21 | Arrowhead Griffins | Yorvit Torrealba | c |
| 22 | Castle Rock Fjords | Adam Hyzdu | cf |
| 23 | Atlanta Arrogants | Dennis Tankersley | sp |
| 24 | Rapid City Mudhens | Ricky Stone | mr |
| Selection | Team | Player | Position |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Castle Rock Fjords | Miguel Asencio | sp |
| 2 | Kansas City Revenants | Travis Driskill | mr |
| 3 | New York Jaywalkers | Andy Van Hekken | sp |
| 4 | Braidwood Blast | Angel Berroa | ss |
| 5 | Mentone Beach Maulers | Willie Harris | lf |
| 6 | Miami Mercenaries | Justin Miller | mr |
| 7 | Atlanta Arrogants | Jayson Durocher | mr |
| 8 | Rock Creek Disco Dancers | Aaron Harang | sp |
| 9 | Rapid City Mudhens | Kevin Gryboski | mr |
| 10 | Rock Creek Disco Dancers | John McDonald | ss |
| 11 | Rapid City Mudhens | Scott Mullen | mr |
| 12 | Olympia Muscle | Keith Ginter | 2b |
| 13 | Rapid City Mudhens | Brandon Villafuerte | mr |
| 14 | Braidwood Blast | Ben Broussard | 1b |
| 15 | Syracuse Comets | Vance Wilson | c |
| 16 | Kansas City Revenants | Mike Bacsik | sp |
| 17 | Kansas City Revenants | Jose Molina | c |
| 18 | Toronto Storm | Jason Middlebrook | mr |
| 19 | Castle Rock Fjords | Coco Crisp | cf |
| 20 | Mentone Beach Maulers | Corky Miller | c |
| 21 | Kansas City Revenants | Aaron Guiel | cf |
| 22 | Miami Mercenaries | Jason Michaels | lf |
| 23 | Atlanta Arrogants | Blaine Neal | mr |
| 24 | Los Angeles Hogheads | Michael Rivera | c |