| Selection | Team | Player | Position |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Castle Rock Fjords | Mark Teixeira | 1b |
| 2 | New York Jaywalkers | Brandon Webb | sp |
| 3 | Braidwood Blast | Miguel Cabrera | 3b |
| 4 | Scottsdale Cactus Riders | Dontrelle Willis | sp |
| 5 | Charleston Chiefs | Scott Podsednik | lf |
| 6 | Arrowhead Griffins | Rocco Baldelli | rf |
| 7 | Sioux City Soos | Hideki Matsui | dh |
| 8 | Rock Creek Disco Dancers | Jose Contreras | mr |
| 9 | Toronto Storm | Jose Reyes | ss |
| 10 | Rapid City Mudhens | Jae Seo | sp |
| 11 | Scottsdale Cactus Riders | Rich Harden | sp |
| 12 | Syracuse Comets | Jody Gerut | cf |
| 13 | Castle Rock Fjords | Jerome Williams | sp |
| 14 | Castle Rock Fjords | Marlon Byrd | rf |
| 15 | Scottsdale Cactus Riders | Victor Martinez | dh |
| 16 | Baldwin Bombers | Jason Phillips | c |
| 17 | Rapid City Mudhens | Horacio Ramirez | mr |
| 18 | Atlanta Arrogants | Justin Morneau | 1b |
| 19 | Charleston Chiefs | Brandon Phillips | 2b |
| 20 | Scottsdale Cactus Riders | Travis Hafner | dh |
| 21 | Castle Rock Fjords | Ken Harvey | 1b |
| 22 | Las Vegas DiamondBucks | Jason Bay | lf |
| 23 | Charleston Chiefs | Francisco Rodriguez | mr |
| 24 | Scottsdale Cactus Riders | Laynce Nix | rf |
| Selection | Team | Player | Position |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Castle Rock Fjords | Oscar Villarreal | mr |
| 2 | New York Jaywalkers | Cliff Lee | sp |
| 3 | Braidwood Blast | Brad Lidge | mr |
| 4 | Los Angeles Hogheads | Andrew Good | mr |
| 5 | Charleston Chiefs | Lyle Overbay | 1b |
| 6 | Arrowhead Griffins | Miguel Olivo | c |
| 7 | Sioux City Soos | Eric Munson | c |
| 8 | Castle Rock Fjords | Chone Figgins | lf |
| 9 | Scottsdale Cactus Riders | Jeremy Bonderman | mr |
| 10 | Castle Rock Fjords | Hee Seop Choi | 1b |
| 11 | Las Vegas DiamondBucks | Jason Davis | mr |
| 12 | Syracuse Comets | Claudio Vargas | mr |
| 13 | Castle Rock Fjords | Ray Olmedo | 2b |
| 14 | New York Jaywalkers | Jason Stanford | mr |
| 15 | Baldwin Bombers | Jose Valverde | cl |
| 16 | Baldwin Bombers | Eric DuBose | mr |
| 17 | Bourbonnais Blackbirds | Jesse Foppert | sp |
| 18 | Charleston Chiefs | Aquilino Lopez | mr |
| 19 | New York Jaywalkers | Casey Blake | 3b |
| 20 | Braidwood Blast | Ryan Wagner | mr |
| 21 | Las Vegas DiamondBucks | Grant Balfour | cl |
| 22 | Atlanta Arrogants | Chin-hui Tsao | mr |
| 23 | Braidwood Blast | Jeriome Robertson | sp |
| 24 | Scottsdale Cactus Riders | Chase Utley | 2b |
| Selection | Team | Player | Position |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Rapid City Mudhens | Luis Ayala | mr |
| 2 | New York Jaywalkers | Reed Johnson | rf |
| 3 | Braidwood Blast | Jimmy Gobble | mr |
| 4 | Sioux City Soos | Xavier Nady | lf |
| 5 | Los Angeles Hogheads | Matt Kata | 3b |
| 6 | Arrowhead Griffins | Bo Hart | 2b |
| 7 | Sioux City Soos | Lew Ford | lf |
| 8 | Rock Creek Disco Dancers | Mike Gallo | mr |
| 9 | Mentone Beach Maulers | R.A. Dickey | sp |
| 10 | Braidwood Blast | Robby Hammock | c |
| 11 | Las Vegas DiamondBucks | Doug Waechter | mr |
| 12 | Syracuse Comets | Brian Shouse | mr |
| 13 | Braidwood Blast | Javier Lopez | mr |
| 14 | New York Jaywalkers | Ben Howard | mr |
| 15 | Mentone Beach Maulers | Brandon Larson | 3b |
| 16 | Rapid City Mudhens | Craig Monroe | lf |
| 17 | Bourbonnais Blackbirds | Billy Traber | mr |
| 18 | Rapid City Mudhens | Mike MacDougal | mr |
| 19 | New York Jaywalkers | Alex Escobar | cf |
| 20 | Braidwood Blast | David Ross | c |
| 21 | Charleston Chiefs | Bill Hall | 2b |
| 22 | Toronto Storm | Chad Gaudin | mr |
| 23 | Braidwood Blast | Brooks Kieschnick | mr |
| 24 | Olympia Muscle | Rafael Betancourt | cl |
| Selection | Team | Player | Position |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Rapid City Mudhens | Kevin Correia | sp |
| 2 | New York Jaywalkers | Robb Quinlan | 1b |
| 3 | Braidwood Blast | Dan Haren | sp |
| 4 | Toronto Blizzard | Antonio Perez | 3b |
| 5 | Charleston Chiefs | Kevin Cash | c |
| 6 | Atlanta Arrogants | Dewon Brazelton | mr |
| 7 | Sioux City Soos | Todd Sears | 1b |
| 8 | Rock Creek Disco Dancers | Nate Robertson | sp |
| 9 | Santa Monica Beach Bums | Aaron Heilman | mr |
| 10 | Baldwin Bombers | Chris Capuano | sp |
| 11 | Toronto Blizzard | Kyle Snyder | mr |
| 12 | Mentone Beach Maulers | Erasmo Ramirez | mr |
| 13 | Mentone Beach Maulers | Adam Melhuse | c |
| 14 | Las Vegas DiamondBucks | Jhonny Peralta | ss |
| 15 | Olympia Muscle | Gerald Laird | c |
| 16 | Kansas City Revenants | D.J. Carrasco | mr |
| 17 | Bourbonnais Blackbirds | Franklyn German | mr |
| 18 | Charleston Chiefs | Eric Eckenstahler | mr |
| 19 | Charleston Chiefs | Wes Obermueller | mr |
| 20 | Mentone Beach Maulers | Wily Mo Pena | dh |
| 21 | Charleston Chiefs | Trey Hodges | mr |
| 22 | Santa Monica Beach Bums | Alfredo Amezaga | 2b |
| 23 | Toronto Storm | Tommy Phelps | mr |
| 24 | Olympia Muscle | Ryan Freel | rf |