| Selection | Team | Player | Position |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Baldwin Bombers | Zack Greinke | sp |
| 2 | New York Jaywalkers | Joe Mauer | c |
| 3 | Scottsdale Cactus Riders | Khalil Greene | ss |
| 4 | Riverside Ramblers | Bobby Crosby | ss |
| 5 | Braidwood Blast | David Wright | 3b |
| 6 | Santa Monica Beach Bums | Scott Kazmir | sp |
| 7 | Castle Rock Fjords | B.J. Upton | cf |
| 8 | Syracuse Comets | Matt Holliday | lf |
| 9 | Baldwin Bombers | Alex Rios | rf |
| 10 | Rapid City Mudhens | David DeJesus | cf |
| 11 | Santa Monica Beach Bums | Kevin Youkilis | 3b |
| 12 | Rapid City Mudhens | John Buck | c |
| 13 | Miami Mercenaries | Noah Lowry | sp |
| 14 | Olympia Muscle | So Taguchi | lf |
| 15 | Miami Mercenaries | Dave Bush | mr |
| 16 | Sioux City Soos | Shingo Takatsu | mr |
| 17 | Rock Creek Disco Dancers | Terrmel Sledge | lf |
| 18 | New York Jaywalkers | Casey Kotchman | 1b |
| 19 | Bourbonnais Blackbirds | Grady Sizemore | cf |
| 20 | Olympia Muscle | Kazuo Matsui | 2b |
| 21 | Arrowhead Griffins | Chad Tracy | 3b |
| 22 | New York Jaywalkers | Jeff Francis | sp |
| 23 | Santa Monica Beach Bums | Scott Hairston | rf |
| 24 | Los Angeles Hogheads | David Newhan | 2b |
| Selection | Team | Player | Position |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Baldwin Bombers | Russ Adams | ss |
| 2 | New York Jaywalkers | Luke Hudson | sp |
| 3 | New York Jaywalkers | Gavin Floyd | sp |
| 4 | Riverside Ramblers | Daniel Cabrera | sp |
| 5 | Braidwood Blast | Ryan Madson | cl |
| 6 | Olympia Muscle | Ross Gload | 1b |
| 7 | Kansas City Revenants | Akinori Otsuka | mr |
| 8 | Santa Monica Beach Bums | Jesse Crain | mr |
| 9 | Rapid City Mudhens | Adam LaRoche | 1b |
| 10 | Rapid City Mudhens | Chad Cordero | cl |
| 11 | Camden Evolution | Travis Blackley | mr |
| 12 | Olympia Muscle | Calvin Pickering | dh |
| 13 | Santa Monica Beach Bums | Aaron Miles | 2b |
| 14 | Scottsdale Cactus Riders | Clint Barmes | ss |
| 15 | Toronto Storm | Erik Bedard | sp |
| 16 | Scottsdale Cactus Riders | Michael Gonzalez | mr |
| 17 | Rock Creek Disco Dancers | Yhency Brazoban | cl |
| 18 | New York Jaywalkers | Charles Thomas | lf |
| 19 | Bourbonnais Blackbirds | Ben Hendrickson | sp |
| 20 | Braidwood Blast | Bobby Madritsch | sp |
| 21 | Arrowhead Griffins | Justin Duchscherer | sp |
| 22 | Scottsdale Cactus Riders | Kevin Gregg | cl |
| 23 | Scottsdale Cactus Riders | Frank Francisco | cl |
| 24 | Braidwood Blast | Luis A. Gonzalez | 2b |
| Selection | Team | Player | Position |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Olympia Muscle | Greg Aquino | mr |
| 2 | Castle Rock Fjords | Duaner Sanchez | mr |
| 3 | Las Vegas DiamondBucks | J.D. Closser | c |
| 4 | Riverside Ramblers | Jason Frasor | mr |
| 5 | Olympia Muscle | Jayson Werth | rf |
| 6 | Olympia Muscle | Jorge Piedra | rf |
| 7 | Rapid City Mudhens | Mike Adams | mr |
| 8 | Syracuse Comets | Matt Miller | mr |
| 9 | Castle Rock Fjords | Yadier Molina | c |
| 10 | Olympia Muscle | Jorge Cantu | 1b |
| 11 | Braidwood Blast | Jose Lopez | 3b |
| 12 | Castle Rock Fjords | Chad Qualls | mr |
| 13 | Braidwood Blast | Neal Cotts | mr |
| 14 | Arrowhead Griffins | Bucky Jacobsen | 1b |
| 15 | Baldwin Bombers | Maicer Izturis | 2b |
| 16 | Olympia Muscle | Humberto Cota | c |
| 17 | Rock Creek Disco Dancers | Gabe Gross | rf |
| 18 | Toronto Storm | Chris Snyder | c |
| 19 | Olympia Muscle | Eric Valent | lf |
| 20 | Los Angeles Hogheads | Luis Terrero | cf |
| 21 | Arrowhead Griffins | Nook Logan | cf |
| 22 | Baldwin Bombers | Chris Young | sp |
| 23 | Castle Rock Fjords | Jose Castillo | 3b |
| 24 | Olympia Muscle | Tim Raines | cf |
| Selection | Team | Player | Position |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Las Vegas DiamondBucks | Ruben Gotay | 3b |
| 2 | Santa Monica Beach Bums | Guillermo Quiroz | c |
| 3 | Las Vegas DiamondBucks | Brad Hawpe | 1b |
| 4 | Riverside Ramblers | Tim Harikkala | mr |
| 5 | Braidwood Blast | Matt Riley | sp |
| 6 | Kansas City Revenants | Shawn Camp | mr |
| 7 | Kansas City Revenants | Abraham Nunez | rf |
| 8 | Syracuse Comets | Nick Green | ss |
| 9 | Camden Evolution | Denny Bautista | mr |
| 10 | Olympia Muscle | Sergio Mitre | mr |
| 11 | Camden Evolution | Joe Borchard | rf |
| 12 | Las Vegas DiamondBucks | J.J. Putz | mr |
| 13 | Santa Monica Beach Bums | Justin Leone | 3b |
| 14 | Las Vegas DiamondBucks | Josh Hancock | sp |
| 15 | Camden Evolution | Sean Burnett | mr |
| 16 | Atlanta Arrogants | Tyler Walker | mr |
| 17 | Rock Creek Disco Dancers | John Van Benschoten | sp |
| 18 | Toronto Storm | Brad Halsey | sp |
| 19 | Bourbonnais Blackbirds | Lance Cormier | mr |
| 20 | Starved Rock Magi | Francis Beltran | mr |
| 21 | Braidwood Blast | Brad Hennessey | mr |
| 22 | Olympia Muscle | Jimmy Serrano | sp |
| 23 | Rapid City Mudhens | Brandon Claussen | sp |
| 24 | Mentone Beach Maulers | Mike Wood | mr |