| Selection | Team | Player | Position |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Baldwin Bombers | Felix Hernandez | sp |
| 2 | Phoenix Monsoon | Jonny Gomes | lf |
| 3 | New York Jaywalkers | Ryan Howard | 1b |
| 4 | Bourbonnais Blackbirds | Zach Duke | mr |
| 5 | Bourbonnais Blackbirds | Huston Street | cl |
| 6 | Baldwin Bombers | Matt Cain | sp |
| 7 | New York Jaywalkers | Jeff Francoeur | rf |
| 8 | New York Jaywalkers | Joe Blanton | sp |
| 9 | Mentone Beach Maulers | Rickie Weeks | 2b |
| 10 | Toronto Storm | Nick Swisher | 1b |
| 11 | Rock Creek Disco Dancers | Tadahito Iguchi | 2b |
| 12 | Rapid City Mudhens | Robinson Cano | 2b |
| 13 | Arrowhead Griffins | Ervin Santana | sp |
| 14 | Castle Rock Fjords | Jonathan Papelbon | cl |
| 15 | Camden Evolution | Conor Jackson | 1b |
| 16 | Scottsdale Cactus Riders | Chris Shelton | 1b |
| 17 | Miami Mercenaries | Gustavo Chacin | mr |
| 18 | Mentone Beach Maulers | Mike Jacobs | dh |
| 19 | Braidwood Blast | Willy Taveras | cf |
| 20 | Syracuse Comets | Scott Baker | sp |
| 21 | Starved Rock Magi | Paul Maholm | sp |
| 22 | Rapid City Mudhens | Garrett Atkins | 1b |
| 23 | Atlanta Arrogants | Brian McCann | c |
| 24 | Scottsdale Cactus Riders | Curtis Granderson | cf |
| Selection | Team | Player | Position |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Starved Rock Magi | Matt Murton | rf |
| 2 | Mentone Beach Maulers | Dallas McPherson | 3b |
| 3 | Syracuse Comets | Brandon McCarthy | sp |
| 4 | Mentone Beach Maulers | Dan Johnson | dh |
| 5 | Las Vegas DiamondBucks | J.J. Hardy | ss |
| 6 | Starved Rock Magi | Lance Niekro | 1b |
| 7 | Camden Evolution | Chris Burke | ss |
| 8 | Syracuse Comets | Dioner Navarro | c |
| 9 | Castle Rock Fjords | Edwin Encarnacion | 1b |
| 10 | Syracuse Comets | Jeremy Reed | lf |
| 11 | Rock Creek Disco Dancers | Yuniesky Betancourt | 3b |
| 12 | Riverside Ramblers | Aaron Hill | 2b |
| 13 | Arrowhead Griffins | Ryan Langerhans | 1b |
| 14 | Camden Evolution | Dustin McGowan | mr |
| 15 | Syracuse Comets | Victor Diaz | rf |
| 16 | Camden Evolution | Kyle Davies | sp |
| 17 | Toronto Storm | Hayden Penn | sp |
| 18 | Syracuse Comets | Fernando Cabrera | mr |
| 19 | Braidwood Blast | Chien-Ming Wang | sp |
| 20 | Syracuse Comets | Jason Vargas | sp |
| 21 | Syracuse Comets | Ryan Shealy | 1b |
| 22 | Rapid City Mudhens | Adrian Gonzalez | 1b |
| 23 | Scottsdale Cactus Riders | Bobby Jenks | mr |
| 24 | Riverside Ramblers | Robinson Tejeda | mr |
| Selection | Team | Player | Position |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Las Vegas DiamondBucks | Juan Dominguez | mr |
| 2 | Rapid City Mudhens | Kelly Johnson | lf |
| 3 | Kansas City Crown Royals | Kameron Loe | mr |
| 4 | Kansas City Crown Royals | Andrew Sisco | mr |
| 5 | Las Vegas DiamondBucks | Wilson Betemit | dh |
| 6 | Syracuse Comets | Willy Aybar | dh |
| 7 | Camden Evolution | Ryan Church | rf |
| 8 | Syracuse Comets | Jose Capellan | mr |
| 9 | Kansas City Crown Royals | Chris Ray | mr |
| 10 | Camden Evolution | Joey Gathright | cf |
| 11 | Rock Creek Disco Dancers | Ian Snell | sp |
| 12 | Camden Evolution | Edwin Jackson | sp |
| 13 | Arrowhead Griffins | Ryan Doumit | dh |
| 14 | Castle Rock Fjords | Brad Thompson | mr |
| 15 | Camden Evolution | Jason Bartlett | ss |
| 16 | Rapid City Mudhens | Clay Hensley | mr |
| 17 | Miami Mercenaries | Wandy Rodriguez | sp |
| 18 | Sioux City Soos | Ezequiel Astacio | sp |
| 19 | Braidwood Blast | Ronny Cedeno | ss |
| 20 | Camden Evolution | John Maine | sp |
| 21 | Las Vegas DiamondBucks | Chad Orvella | mr |
| 22 | Rapid City Mudhens | Michael Morse | rf |
| 23 | Camden Evolution | Chris Duffy | cf |
| 24 | Castle Rock Fjords | Justin Huber | 1b |
| Selection | Team | Player | Position |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Riverside Ramblers | Matt Guerrier | mr |
| 2 | Camden Evolution | Brandon League | mr |
| 3 | Syracuse Comets | D.J. Houlton | mr |
| 4 | Kansas City Crown Royals | Freddy Sanchez | 2b |
| 5 | Las Vegas DiamondBucks | Ben Johnson | rf |
| 6 | Scottsdale Cactus Riders | Cory Sullivan | lf |
| 7 | Camden Evolution | Brad Eldred | 1b |
| 8 | Syracuse Comets | Ambiorix Burgos | mr |
| 9 | Arrowhead Griffins | Will Ohman | mr |
| 10 | Los Angeles Hogheads | Matt Belisle | mr |
| 11 | Rock Creek Disco Dancers | Nate McLouth | lf |
| 12 | Baldwin Bombers | J.P. Howell | mr |
| 13 | Mentone Beach Maulers | Mark Teahen | 3b |
| 14 | Arrowhead Griffins | Tim Stauffer | mr |
| 15 | Camden Evolution | Blaine Boyer | mr |
| 16 | Camden Evolution | Todd Coffey | mr |
| 17 | Miami Mercenaries | Brandon Medders | mr |
| 18 | Sioux City Soos | Pete Orr | lf |
| 19 | Braidwood Blast | John Rodriguez | lf |
| 20 | Starved Rock Magi | Jason Ellison | rf |
| 21 | Starved Rock Magi | Todd Linden | lf |
| 22 | Mentone Beach Maulers | Shane Costa | lf |
| 23 | Mentone Beach Maulers | Dana Eveland | mr |
| 24 | Castle Rock Fjords | Marcos Carvajal | mr |