| Selection | Team | Player | Position |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Castle Rock Fjords | Justin Verlander | sp |
| 2 | Camden Evolution | Delmon Young | rf |
| 3 | Los Angeles Hogheads | Jered Weaver | sp |
| 4 | Las Vegas Diamondbucks | Hanley Ramirez | ss |
| 5 | Rapid City Mudhens | Ryan Zimmerman | 3b |
| 6 | Sioux City Soos | Cole Hamels | sp |
| 7 | Syracuse Comets | Anibal Sanchez | sp |
| 8 | Starved Rock Magi | Francisco Liriano | sp |
| 9 | Las Vegas Diamondbucks | Prince Fielder | 1b |
| 10 | Arrowhead Griffins | Nick Markakis | rf |
| 11 | Braidwood Blast | Russell Martin | c |
| 12 | Los Angeles Hogheads | Kenji Johjima | c |
| 13 | Castle Rock Fjords | Ian Kinsler | 2b |
| 14 | Atlanta Arrogants | Joel Zumaya | mr |
| 15 | Baldwin Bombers | Stephen Drew | ss |
| 16 | Bourbonnais Blackbirds | Jeremy Hermida | rf |
| 17 | Atlanta Arrogants | Matt Garza | sp |
| 18 | Atlanta Arrogants | Chris B. Young | cf |
| 19 | Miami Mercenaries | Josh Johnson | sp |
| 20 | Las Vegas Diamondbucks | Carlos Quentin | rf |
| 21 | Brooklyn Brawlers | Howie Kendrick | 1b |
| 22 | Scottsdale Cactus Riders | Scott Olsen | sp |
| 23 | Starved Rock Magi | Rich Hill | sp |
| 24 | Baldwin Bombers | Chad Billingsley | sp |
| Selection | Team | Player | Position |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Castle Rock Fjords | Adam Wainwright | mr |
| 2 | Camden Evolution | Adam Loewen | sp |
| 3 | Brooklyn Brawlers | Jeremy Sowers | sp |
| 4 | Las Vegas Diamondbucks | Chuck James | sp |
| 5 | Los Angeles Hogheads | Takashi Saito | cl |
| 6 | Sioux City Soos | Boof Bonser | sp |
| 7 | Syracuse Comets | Dan Uggla | 2b |
| 8 | Brooklyn Brawlers | Matt Kemp | cf |
| 9 | Las Vegas Diamondbucks | Josh Barfield | 2b |
| 10 | Arrowhead Griffins | Jonathan Broxton | mr |
| 11 | Braidwood Blast | Tom Gorzelanny | sp |
| 12 | Los Angeles Hogheads | Andre Ethier | lf |
| 13 | Rapid City Mudhens | Josh Willingham | lf |
| 14 | Sioux City Soos | Ronny Paulino | c |
| 15 | Baldwin Bombers | Anthony Reyes | sp |
| 16 | Bourbonnais Blackbirds | Andy Marte | 3b |
| 17 | Baldwin Bombers | James Loney | 1b |
| 18 | Atlanta Arrogants | Corey Hart | rf |
| 19 | Miami Mercenaries | Melky Cabrera | lf |
| 20 | Scottsdale Cactus Riders | Troy Tulowitzki | ss |
| 21 | Riverside Ramblers | Lastings Milledge | rf |
| 22 | Brooklyn Brawlers | Kendry Morales | 1b |
| 23 | Syracuse Comets | Chris Duncan | lf |
| 24 | Mentone Beach Maulers | Cla Meredith | mr |
| Selection | Team | Player | Position |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Mentone Beach Maulers | Joe Saunders | sp |
| 2 | Camden Evolution | Chris Iannetta | c |
| 3 | Los Angeles Hogheads | Mike Napoli | c |
| 4 | Los Angeles Hogheads | Jason Kubel | lf |
| 5 | Los Angeles Hogheads | Matt Capps | mr |
| 6 | Sioux City Soos | Taylor Tankersley | mr |
| 7 | Rapid City Mudhens | Ryan Garko | 1b |
| 8 | Baldwin Bombers | Pat Neshek | mr |
| 9 | Starved Rock Magi | Wes Littleton | mr |
| 10 | Arrowhead Griffins | Ricky Nolasco | sp |
| 11 | Braidwood Blast | Jonathan Sanchez | mr |
| 12 | Brooklyn Brawlers | Dustin Pedroia | 2b |
| 13 | Castle Rock Fjords | Sean Marshall | sp |
| 14 | Sioux City Soos | Zach Miner | sp |
| 15 | Castle Rock Fjords | Macay McBride | mr |
| 16 | Bourbonnais Blackbirds | Fernando Nieve | mr |
| 17 | Castle Rock Fjords | Brian Anderson | cf |
| 18 | Atlanta Arrogants | Esteban German | 3b |
| 19 | Baldwin Bombers | Jon Lester | sp |
| 20 | Toronto Blizzard | Eliezer Alfonzo | c |
| 21 | Riverside Ramblers | Adam Jones | cf |
| 22 | Scottsdale Cactus Riders | James Shields | sp |
| 23 | Castle Rock Fjords | Jeff Mathis | c |
| 24 | Mentone Beach Maulers | Casey Janssen | sp |
| Selection | Team | Player | Position |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Castle Rock Fjords | Fausto Carmona | mr |
| 2 | Atlanta Arrogants | Hong-Chih Kuo | mr |
| 3 | Los Angeles Hogheads | Carlos Villanueva | sp |
| 4 | Mentone Beach Maulers | Chris Britton | mr |
| 5 | Riverside Ramblers | Jason Hirsh | sp |
| 6 | Sioux City Soos | Shin-Soo Choo | rf |
| 7 | Rapid City Mudhens | Fabio Castro | mr |
| 8 | Mentone Beach Maulers | Nelson Cruz | rf |
| 9 | Castle Rock Fjords | Enrique Gonzalez | sp |
| 10 | Arrowhead Griffins | Carlos Marmol | sp |
| 11 | Braidwood Blast | Mike O'Connor | sp |
| 12 | Toronto Blizzard | David Aardsma | mr |
| 13 | Baldwin Bombers | Craig Hansen | mr |
| 14 | Mentone Beach Maulers | Taylor Buchholz | sp |
| 15 | Riverside Ramblers | Chris Snelling | rf |
| 16 | Bourbonnais Blackbirds | Edinson Volquez | sp |
| 17 | Starved Rock Magi | Tony Gwynn | cf |
| 18 | Atlanta Arrogants | Scott Thorman | lf |
| 19 | Miami Mercenaries | Ruddy Lugo | mr |
| 20 | Mentone Beach Maulers | Ryan Theriot | 2b |
| 21 | Riverside Ramblers | Kelly Shoppach | c |
| 22 | Mentone Beach Maulers | Chris Denorfia | rf |
| 23 | Baldwin Bombers | Yusmeiro Petit | mr |
| 24 | Arrowhead Griffins | Emiliano Fruto | mr |